Backyard Breeder Signs Every Maine Coon Buyer Should Recognize
November 15, 2023|Kittens

Searching for a good breeder and a sweet Maine Coon kitten ought to be a happy, unforgettable experience, for all the right reasons! Sadly, plenty of hopeful Maine Coon families end up buying from ‘backyard breeders’ instead of a reputable breeder worthy of their trust.
Backyard breeding means producing Maine Coon kittens irresponsibly, frequently in poor conditions and with too little care, by people who do not have the right resources, experience, or knowledge. A few backyard breeders adore their cats and mean well, yet they simply do not have the funds or the skill to run a proper program. Others are in it for the money. They notice what a well-bred Maine Coon kitten costs and assume breeding is an easy way to earn some cash. They have no idea what it really costs to meet the special needs of intact males, expectant mothers, and their babies. And they rarely understand the sheer effort, the blood, sweat, and tears, behind breeding ethically.
Backyard breeders keep ethical breeders up at night, because in their care the Maine Coons we cherish suffer for no good reason. Our concerns include poor nutrition, parasite problems (e.g., fleas and worms), infectious diseases (e.g., fungal infections, FIV), behavioral troubles, and inherited health issues, all of which put these defenseless cats and kittens in danger. Health and temperament problems that surface can also carry into later generations of Maine Coons.
Telling Good Breeders From Risky Ones
Vetting Maine Coon breeders and choosing one is simple once you know which questions to ask and which answers should rule a breeder out. This is a big commitment of both money and heart, so move slowly and choose carefully!
QUESTION 1. Which health tests do you run, and what health guarantee comes with your kittens?
A common backyard breeder sign is incomplete health testing: these breeders usually do not run every test their breeding cats need. Whatever they may believe, DNA testing by itself is not sufficient! At the very least, any cat in a breeding program needs:
- Genetic (DNA) tests for the HCM, PkDef, SMA and PKD mutations
- PCR tests to check for upper respiratory diseases
- Fecal float tests to screen for parasites
- Echocardiograms to check for signs of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM)
- X-ray screening for hip dysplasia
An ethical breeder completes every one of these tests on each parent cat and shares the results whenever you request them. Confident in the health of their cats, they sell kittens under a written contract with a thorough health guarantee. Genetic conditions should be covered for no less than a year (at Maine Street Coons, our coverage for genetic conditions lasts a full five years). Some contracts include sympathy provisions for FIP or hip dysplasia. A breeder cannot directly control these conditions, yet an outstanding breeder will still offer some kind of discount on a future kitten if a health problem affects your kitten early in life.
2. When may I tour the cattery and see the spaces your cats and kittens call home?
Raising Maine Coons takes plenty of clean, climate-controlled, well-ventilated, bright space. And we mean plenty, truly A LOT, of room! At the very least, a cattery needs:
- A quarantine area for cats that are ill or newly added to the program.
- Separate areas for intact males so no accidental matings happen.
- Separate areas where pregnant Queens can be kept apart before, during, and for weeks after giving birth
- Room where toddler kittens can play and explore safely
Each of these areas should be livable by human standards. Rooms where the cats stay should be clean, mostly free of odor (apart from the unavoidable smell of intact males), and thoughtfully furnished so the cats get both mental enrichment and physical activity. Here at Maine Street Coons, every one of our cats lives inside our home with us, and we have changed our house a great deal to make that work. We remodeled several rooms into separate spaces and gave the cats generous areas devoted to their play and well-being.
3. How old are your kittens when they go home?
For the best possible health and temperament, a skilled breeder keeps each Maine Coon kitten with its mother for at least twelve weeks. The best window for adoption is between 13 and 15 weeks of age. Kittens keep picking up skills from their mother and littermates well after weaning, and their immunity needs time to mature fully after the third FVCRP shot at 12 weeks. A backyard breeder pushes to sell younger kittens to cut the cost of feeding them once weaned and to get paid as fast as possible.
4. What food do your breeding cats and kittens eat?
To keep prices low and profits high, most backyard breeders choose cheaper, lower-quality food. That is a real shame. Honestly, breeding cats need better nutrition than pets do, both to keep their immune systems strong and to handle the heavy demands of producing and raising healthy kittens. Mother cats need 1.5-3X the nutrition of cats that are not pregnant and should eat a kitten-stage diet suited to their particular needs. Ethical breeders feed an excellent, veterinarian-approved diet made up of an AAFCO-certified dry kibble plus a high-protein wet food. Acceptable brands include Royal Canin, Nulo, ND (Farmina), Weruva, Stella & Chewy's, and TikiCat.
5. What veterinary care do your cats and kittens receive, and how often?
Every breeding cat needs a yearly health exam and echocardiogram, along with all the appropriate screenings, vaccinations, and dental care at those visits. Kittens should visit a vet no fewer than three times before they leave: first at 6-7 weeks, again at 9-10 weeks, and once more at 12-13 weeks. Steer clear of backyard breeders who handle health care themselves or give their own vaccines.
6. What support will you give us once our kitten comes home?
Asking about support after your kitten goes home is one of the simplest ways to tell a backyard breeder from a reputable, ethical one. How a breeder responds tells you a great deal about how committed they are to the kittens they bring into the world and the families those kittens join.
- Will you check in often during the first few weeks or months to be sure things are going well?
- If a health concern comes up, will you be available to talk with us or our veterinarian?
- If behavior or adjustment problems arise, will you help me work through them?
- How often do you want updates from me, and on what topics?
- If I am ever unable to care for the kitten properly, will you offer it a home?
7. How much is your adoption fee, and what does it cover?
You know the old line: "If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is." Be very wary of any Maine Coon breeder selling kittens for far below the typical price in your part of the country. Plenty of backyard breeders try to win buyers from ethical breeders by trimming costs and lowering prices. For you, sadly, that can mean a kitten that arrives with expensive problems and even contagious illnesses that could spread to you or your kids. With something as precious as a life, pay more at the start and spare yourself a great deal of grief later.
The Bottom Line
To wrap up, here are the Top 10 red flags that tell you a backyard breeder is on the other end.
- The breeder depends only on DNA testing and/or wrongly assumes every case of HCM has a genetic cause
- The breeder asks hardly anything about your home or whether you can properly care for a Maine Coon
- The breeder lets kittens leave their mother before 12 weeks
- You are not permitted to visit the breeder's home or the areas where kittens are raised
- Nobody suggests you meet the kitten's parents during your visit or at pickup
- The breeder appears to know little about the breed or does not take time to teach you how to care for a Maine Coon
- The breeder is reluctant to answer your questions or dodges them by switching topics
- The breeder provides only a bare-bones health guarantee or a flimsy written contract
- The breeder does not prohibit declawing, require spaying or neutering, or require that the cat live indoors
If a Maine Coon is going to join your family, do your homework and choose your breeder first! Stay away from backyard breeders entirely, however adorable the kitten, brief the waitlist, or low the price!