Skip to content

Articles & resources for maine coon enthusiasts

An informative blog series for current and hopeful Maine Coon owners.

All Posts

Toby’s Story: An Award-Winning Maine Coon Who Is So Much More

June 15, 2026|Show Cats

Toby’s Story: An Award-Winning Maine Coon Who Is So Much More, Maine Street Coons

The day MaineStCoons Toe Be or Not Toe Be, whom we all call Toby, was born, we could never have guessed how far his path would lead.

We did know that he stood for everything we cherish as preservation breeders: outstanding health, a sweet and self-assured temperament, and faithfulness to the written breed standard that has shaped the Maine Coon for generations.

Today, Toby has accomplished what very few cats ever will.

This award-winning Maine Coon is a TICA International Winner and a two-time International Breed Winner, and he ranked in the Top 25 Cats of All Breeds Worldwide for the 2025-2026 show season.

To people outside the cat fancy, those titles may simply sound grand. To anyone familiar with pedigreed cats, they stand for years of commitment, remarkable consistency and a level of success that only a few cats ever reach.

Toby’s Story: An Award-Winning Maine Coon Who Is So Much More, Maine Street Coons

What Does It Mean to Be a TICA International Winner?

No single judge, single show or single weekend of competition can award the International Winner title.

Across a full show season, cats are judged by dozens of judges at many different shows, often traveling thousands of miles to face the best examples of every recognized breed. Every ring is a separate evaluation by a different judge, so consistency is everything.

One brilliant day is never enough to earn an International Win. A cat has to prove itself over and over, before different judges, in different regions and against outstanding rivals.

Each year, only a tiny number of cats around the world earn this honor.

A spot on that Top 25 Cats of All Breeds Worldwide list requires succeeding against thousands of cats from every breed TICA recognizes.

For any cat, that is an extraordinary achievement.

For a polydactyl Maine Coon, it is more remarkable still.

Toby’s Story: An Award-Winning Maine Coon Who Is So Much More, Maine Street Coons

The Challenge of Standing Out

Polydactyl Maine Coons are nothing new. Extra toes belong to the breed’s history and were common among the tough working cats of the New England coast.

Even with that historic importance, polydactyls have often had to fight an uphill battle at shows.

For years, some breeders and exhibitors saw polydactyls as a curiosity instead of a meaningful part of the breed’s heritage. Attitudes have improved enormously, but traces of those old views can still remain.

The truth is that a polydactyl cannot count on extra toes to win over judges.

Often, it is just the reverse.

To climb to the highest levels of competition, a polydactyl has to excel in every other part of the breed standard.

Type, balance, structure, boning, muzzle, profile, ear set, coat quality, condition and temperament all have to be outstanding. There is simply no room for a weak point.

Extra toes are not why a great polydactyl wins.

A great polydactyl wins because judges know excellence when they see it, and the cat's quality is simply too strong to ignore.

Toby’s success sends an important signal: a polydactyl Maine Coon that is historically correct can compete shoulder-to-shoulder with the best cats in the world and be judged purely on merit.

Toby’s Story: An Award-Winning Maine Coon Who Is So Much More, Maine Street Coons

What Toby Stands For

We are tremendously proud of the title Toby earned, yet the award is not what matters most to us.

Toby is the result of careful breeding choices, thorough health testing, pedigree research, mentorship and a steadfast dedication to keeping the authentic American Maine Coon alive. He shows that breeders do not have to pick between health, temperament and beauty.

The finest Maine Coons should have all three.

People who meet Toby usually notice his size and presence first. What stays with them, though, is his personality. He is loving, confident and closely bonded to people, the same traits that have made Maine Coons cherished family companions all over the world.

To us, that temperament matters every bit as much as his show record.

Toby’s Story: An Award-Winning Maine Coon Who Is So Much More, Maine Street Coons

The Road Ahead

We will always treasure Toby’s International Winner title as a milestone, but his story does not end here.

Even more importantly, the story continues through the generations that come after him.

Each preservation breeder dreams of leaving the breed in better shape than they found it. Toby reflects how devoted we are to that goal and how firmly we believe that the Maine Coon's future rests on protecting what made the breed special from the start: sound health, steady temperament, correct type and respect for its rich history.

We feel honored that judges across the globe saw those qualities in Toby.

To us, though, he will always be exactly who he was from day one:

A cherished member of our family, and one truly special cat.

Toby’s Story: An Award-Winning Maine Coon Who Is So Much More, Maine Street Coons