How to Pick a Maine Coon Kitten: 5 Tips for Choosing a Future Beauty
November 6, 2023|Kittens
Beyond their wonderful personalities, Maine Coons are famous for being big, gorgeous cats with long, flowing coats. Admirers adore their lion-like manes and tufted ears. They marvel at the breed's strength, sturdy boning and muscular build. Still others fall for that luxuriously long, bushy tail or the soft tufts of hair between the toes.
All of that describes a well-bred adult, but you won't see every one of those traits in a young kitten. Maine Coons mature more slowly than any other cat breed. In fact, a Maine Coon kitten can take up to four years to grow into its full adult potential. So if you are learning how to pick a Maine Coon kitten that is only a few weeks old, remember that it still has a great deal of growing ahead!
Keep these points in mind as you judge a young Maine Coon kitten's looks:
- A kitten's coat changes a lot on its way to adulthood. Those changes affect how long, what color, how textured and how dense the coat becomes.
- On a smoke or silver kitten, the color can look very dark or very pale as the coat moves through its stages of development.
- A reddish tint may show up in the coat, caused by a chemical reaction to the mother's saliva while she grooms her baby.
- A ruff may or may not be present. Some kittens have one from birth, while others won't grow one until they pass their first birthday.
- At birth, a Maine Coon kitten's ears sit tight and close against the head. Within a few weeks they turn rounded and poke out to the sides, much like a bear cub's. By go-home time, the ears have moved up to the top of the head, where they can seem a bit oversized until the head matures and everything comes into proportion.
- The tail may begin fairly thin, looking much like the tail of an ordinary domestic long-haired cat.
So How Do You Choose a Kitten From a Breeder That Will Grow Into the Adult Maine Coon You Have Always Dreamed Of?
1. Learn the Maine Coon Breed Standard
Everyone has their own taste. Still, if you are investing time and effort in buying a purebred cat, it makes sense to want one that looks the way the breed should! And yes, technically, a Maine Coon's appearance does have a "right and wrong."
Those ideal traits are spelled out in a document called a breed standard. In the United States, the two most popular and respected registries of pedigreed cats, TICA and CFA, each write a standard for the Maine Coon. Reputable breeders rely on these standards to produce kittens of consistent type, and each association's trained judges use them to score cats at shows and choose the winners.
From the moment we first dreamed of breeding Maine Coons, we have been a little obsessed with raising cats that closely match the TICA breed standard. We are devoted to safeguarding the well-being and heritage of these majestic Native American cats, along with the physical beauty they developed while adapting to survive the harsh New England climate where they began. We know that the more closely a Maine Coon matches the breed standard, the better it can produce healthy, purpose-bred kittens that meet the standard too, and that is exactly our goal!
Our cats follow TICA's written breed standard closely, and with every improvement to our breeding program we work to bring our kittens nearer to perfect type. Here is a published copy of TICA's most recent written breed standard.
2. Choose Balance Over Extreme Features
There is one part of the breed standard we need to call out: its strong emphasis on balance. Preservation breeders like us, along with TICA and CFA, put real effort into keeping the original Maine Coon's authentic appearance alive. TICA even revised the wording of its breed standard recently and changed how points are awarded, all to underline how much balance matters.
"Overall balance and proportion are essential to the Maine Coon, and no one feature should dominate the eye’s attention over any other.", TICA breed standard, 2023
Poor breeding, whether on purpose or by accident, has left some Maine Coons with extreme features. We see this often in European Maine Coons. They share the very same DNA as their native American cousins, yet they now look very, very different, because breeders have deliberately selected for deep-set eyes, exaggerated "alligator" muzzles, ears that are too tall or set too close together like a rabbit's, and other traits that create a more extreme, feral appearance.
At Maine Street Coons, we oppose breeding away from the traditional standard, because doing so brings health problems into the breed that would not occur naturally. Many Maine Coons with deep-set or overly slanted eyes, for instance, develop entropion, a painful eye condition that leads to chronic irritation, infection and possible blindness unless it is surgically corrected. We also see breeders who become fixated on size. In chasing a bigger Maine Coon, they often end up with a back that is extremely and disproportionately long, so the legs and tail look short by comparison. Such a cat can suffer the same painful back problems that trouble long-spined dogs such as Dachshunds.
3. Know Which Features Matter Most to You
A perfect cat does not exist, and if one did, no breeder would sell it to you! They would keep that flawless example for showing and for their own breeding program. Rather than chasing perfection, decide which parts of a beautiful, show-winning Maine Coon's look mean the most to you.
- Is it how long and thick the coat is?
- The eye shape?
- A nice square muzzle?
- How long the tail is?
- The furnishings on the ear tips and between the toes?
- Or a particular color or pattern?
Once you understand the breed standard and have a picture of how a show-winning Maine Coon should look, start saving photos of the cats that truly move you. Go back through them and find the 2-3 features they all share. That will tell you a lot about what really draws you to the breed. Next, seek out a breeder who actively shows and whose grown cats display those traits time after time. If everything else checks out, you have found your breeder, and he or she can steer you toward a kitten likely to develop those same features as it grows.
4. Work With an Active Show Breeder
You do not need to buy a "show quality" kitten or pay a premium to bring home a beautiful, affectionate Maine Coon pet. A breeder who wins at shows will know the written standard inside and out and will have a trained eye for kittens and cats that conform to it. Look for someone who enters and wins TICA or CFA cat shows. Their cats will carry titles such as Champion (CH), Grand Champion (GCH) and beyond, and the very best will also have earned Regional Winner (RW) or International Winner (IW) honors. Breeders with titled cats in their program know how to pick a standout kitten from a litter! They are best placed to help you judge whether a kitten's features are right for its age at the time you see it. They understand how their lines develop and can point you to a kitten that will live up to your hopes as it matures.
At Maine Street Coons, we enter TICA cat shows and take an active part, as members, in our Southeast regional club, the Cattyshack cat club. Every TICA show is listed online, and our Facebook events show which ones we plan to attend over the coming months.
5. Study the Kitten's Parents and Grandparents
No domestic cat matures more slowly than the Maine Coon. They don’t truly start coming into their own until their second year, and the Gentle Giant hiding inside does not fully appear until their third full year. Since Maine Coons usually become parents while still young, often at about a year old, the kitten's grandparents may give you a clearer picture of its potential. If mom, dad, grandma or grandpa doesn't appeal to you, that adorable kitten probably won't appeal to you as it grows up either. Studying the past is the surest way to forecast the future!

A dependable way to forecast how your kitten will look and behave is to study the appearance and attitude of its parents. If a big cat matters to you, check the parents' size. If your wish list includes almond-shaped eyes, tall and well-tipped ears or a strong, square muzzle, take a close look at Mama and Dad for those traits.
