Maine Coon Kitten Scams: How to Spot a Scammer Before You Pay
March 27, 2025

Adding a Maine Coon kitten to your life is a thrilling step. These regal cats are loved for their affectionate natures, lush coats, and larger-than-life presence. Unfortunately, as demand for them keeps rising, so does the number of Maine Coon kitten scams aimed at hopeful buyers. At Maine Street Coons, ethical breeding is our passion, and we want to help shield you from heartbreak and lost money.
Below, learn how to recognize a scammer, which red flags to steer clear of, and what to expect from a reputable Maine Coon breeder.
Common Maine Coon Scams and How to Sidestep Them
It breaks our hearts when buyers tell us they were scammed while hunting for their dream kitten. Here are the scams we see most often:
1. Prices That Seem Too Good to Be True
An ad selling Maine Coon kittens for under $2,500 is nearly always a scam. Reputable breeders, hobbyists and professionals alike, spend a great deal on the care, health, and proper raising of their cats. Cutting corners is unethical and hurts the cats. When you spot a kitten listed at a bargain price, RUN the other way. That "kitten" is no bargain, because it does not even exist!
2. Facebook Posts Promising “Maine Coons for Rehoming”
Chances are you have come across social media posts or groups offering Maine Coons in exchange for a modest rehoming fee. Each and every one of these is a scam. Scammers frequently lift photos from real breeders and pretend they are rehoming the cats. The reality? Those kittens are not real. Maine Coons are in such high demand that ethical breeders never need cheap Facebook posts to find homes for their cats.
3. Unsafe Payment Methods
Be very wary of any seller who insists on gift cards, Western Union, or other payments that cannot be traced. Scammers prefer these because they cannot be disputed, so once the money leaves your hands, you will not see it again. Always use a secure, traceable option that protects you if fraud happens, such as PayPal or a credit card.
4. No Home Visits or Live Video Calls
Reputable breeders are proud of their catteries and should be glad to have buyers visit. Seeing where the cats and kittens live reassures you that they are growing up in a clean, loving, healthy home. Some breeders do have privacy or security concerns, but at minimum they should offer a live video call so you can see their home and the kittens.
5. Paying in Full Upfront
A trustworthy breeder will never ask for 100% of the price before you have even met the kitten. Paying a deposit to hold your kitten is normal, but the rest should not be due until your happy, healthy kitten is in your arms. Be careful if someone wants the full amount ahead of time.
6. Misleading TICA Registrations
TICA (The International Cat Association) registration is a valuable credential, yet it does not prove a seller is legitimate. Anyone, scammers included, can register a cattery with TICA for a small fee, and the process involves no inspections or in-depth vetting. Ask breeders how active their TICA involvement is and when they most recently showed a cat. Reputable breeders tend to compete in TICA shows and can point to their wins and awards.
Signs of a Reputable Maine Coon Breeder
With the red flags covered, here is a checklist of the qualities and habits an ethical breeder should have:
1. Active Participation in TICA
A reputable breeder takes part in the cat breeding community and regularly shows cats at TICA events. That involvement reflects a dedication to high breeding standards and to the overall health of the breed.
2. Open Cattery Access
Responsible breeders let prospective buyers come and see their cattery. A visit shows you directly how the cats and kittens are looked after, from cleanliness and space to how they interact with people. If you cannot visit in person, a reputable breeder will set up a live video call and invite you into their home when you come to pick up your kitten.
3. Safe Payment Methods
Choose breeders who take secure payments with buyer protection, such as PayPal or a credit card. These options let you dispute a charge if anything goes wrong, which helps guard you against fraud.
4. Fair Payment Practices
Ethical breeders ask only for a deposit in advance, never the full price. This builds trust on both sides and gives you peace of mind while you wait for your kitten.
5. Solid References
Feel free to ask a breeder for references from earlier buyers. Hearing how other families were treated can reassure you that the breeder is honest and ethical.
6. Health and Welfare Always Come First
A reputable breeder puts their cats' health ahead of everything. Request health records, vaccination details, and genetic test results for the kittens and for their parents. This kind of openness is a clear mark of a breeder who genuinely cares about their animals.
Mistakes to Avoid When Buying a Maine Coon Kitten
Even when you know all of this, slip-ups are easy to make during your search. Steer clear of these common mistakes to protect yourself and keep your adoption happy and ethical:
- Don’t Rush into Decisions: Excitement can push you into acting on impulse. Slow down, watch for red flags, and look into each breeder carefully.
- Don’t Prioritize Price Over Quality: A Maine Coon is an investment. If cost is all you consider, you may end up supporting unethical breeding or being scammed.
- Don’t Skip Research: Look at reviews and references, and check whether the breeder has a track record with shows or groups such as TICA.
- Don’t Be Afraid to Walk Away: When something seems wrong, trust your gut and keep looking. Your peace of mind is worth it.
Final Thoughts
Bringing home a Maine Coon kitten is a happy, rewarding experience, but it takes care to make sure your money supports ethical breeders and not scammers. Watch for red flags, do your homework, and ask the right questions, and you will protect yourself while also helping to care for and preserve this amazing breed.
At Maine Street Coons, we care deeply about the well-being of Maine Coons and about honesty throughout the adoption process. If you have questions about finding a reputable breeder or steering clear of scams, we are happy to help. Your dream kitten is out there, so don't settle for less than they deserve.